Cyrus Everett and Donna Mauch

The Murders of Cyrus Everett and Donna Mauch (Maine)

When a cryptic poem landed on the editor's desk at the Fort Fairfield Review in 1984, it would be the beginning of the end of a 20 year saga that cast a dark shadow over the small Aroostook County town. Two highly publicized murders would go unsolved for two decades until the spider himself got caught in the tangled web he believed he was weaving.

Julie Campbell

The Murder of Julie Campbell (Massachusetts)

43 years have passed since that dark, cold New England night when someone stole the life of Julie Campbell. 43 years have passed without knowing who is responsible for her murder. Here to tell Julie’s story is her younger sister, Lori Manning.

Emma J. Turnbull clipping

The Murder of Emma J. Turnbull (Maine)

Emma J. Turnbull was the widow of Charles Turnbull and mother of eight children. When Harold Turnbull returned home on August 4, 1916 to an alarming scene and his mother nowhere to be found, the frantic search for Mrs. Turnbull became a community-wide effort.

Shirley Coolen and family

The Murder of Shirley Coolen (Maine)

When Zenovia Clegg's killer confessed to his crime, he also revealed small scraps of the secrets he’d been keeping throughout the decades. These are the complex, dark, and interwoven stories of Shirley Coolen, Donna Kimmey, Zenovia Clegg, and Patricia Wing.

Patricia Wing clipping

The Suspicious Death of Patricia Wing (Maine)

The case that unraveled from that 1958 June afternoon would reveal secrets, kept from spouses, an imperfect investigation in a small, rural county dealing with a spike in violent homicides, and a compelling case by the defense that is still questioned to this day -- Was it all a big, unfortunate accident?

Sarah Cherry

The Murder of Sarah Cherry (Maine)

12-year old Sarah Cherry disappeared while babysitting on July 6, 1988. A clue laying in the driveway of the house where she was last seen pointed investigators to their primary suspect, Dennis Dechaine. Retired Detective Dan Reed joins me in the telling of this story.

Leslie Spellman clipping

The Murder of Leslie Spellman (Maine)

Leslie was just 27-years old when she set off to Bar Harbor in the summer of 1977, hitchhiking from Vermont with her scruffy mutt Taylor by her side. Her beaten body would be found just a day after she left for her adventure, along the walking trail at Asticou Gardens in Northeast Harbor. To this day, over 40 years later, Leslie’s family is still searching for answers -- Who took the life of their sweet sister and daughter?