Marc Joyal-Myers was 11-years old when he lost his big brother, 18-year old Robert Joyal. More than two decades have passed since that night in April 1998 when someone ended Rob’s life in a Portland, Maine parking lot.

8-year old Tammy Lynn Belanger was skipping down the road to Lincoln Street School, right on time as she did every day. Except on November 13, 1984, something or someone intercepted her usual route. Tammy Lynn never made it home. She didn't even make it to school.

With Darien’s passing, Portland Police had a homicide investigation on their hands, and a clue still lodged in Darien’s hip would lead them to the first big break in the case… A break that would only take them so far, after a loophole left the investigation stalled at a frustrating dead end.

An unknown gunman fired several rounds into Darien Richardson's bedroom at her Portland, Maine apartment as she and her then-boyfriend lay sleeping. While Darien initially survived, complications from her gunshot wounds would ultimately claim her life just two short months later. Darien's case remains unsolved.

Mattie Hackett was just 17 years old when she was murdered outside her home on Kents Hill. Though nearly 116 years have passed since that August evening when her life was stolen, the answer to Mattie’s mysterious killing was never uncovered. The question remains: Who really killed Mattie Hackett?

Just before 10 p.m. on the night of October 13, 1984, an unknown man pulled into the emergency room drop-off at Eastern Maine Medical Center. He threw open his door and hurried to the attendant on duty. The man didn’t identify himself, or the badly injured woman sitting in his front seat. The driver told hospital staff that she was hit by a car. As they placed the woman in a wheelchair and brought her inside, the driver sped off without another word.

The waters of Casco Bay and Maine’s coast are drenched with tales of shipwrecks and tragedy and lives lost at sea, but among all the true stories and the legends that endure, the story of the Annie C. Maguire is among the most intriguing.

What happened to Luella Blakeslee and Debra Lee Horn? Could their cases share one critical connection to the murder of Susan Randall two years later?

According to the Innocence Project, new DNA evidence and testing has exonerated 192 individuals wrongly convicted of crimes that DNA proved they didn’t commit. Could this be the case of Susan Randall and the man convicted of her murder? Not so fast. I want you to hear the whole story -- Susan Randall’s story. She deserves as much.

It’s time to tell Geraldine Ann Finn’s whole story. Plus, in a special interview with Lt. Jeffery Love, commanding officer of the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit, you’ll hear an update on the case of Janet Brochu, and I ask why it took 34 years to arrest Gerald Goodale for her murder.

When anyone asked where Richard Bellitteri was, the carpenter he hired on Craigslist told them he had a death in the family and went back to New York. A year later, Richard still hadn't returned to his beloved home in the Downeast region of Maine.

This is the story of a woman’s life stolen, a bizarre confession and imperfect investigation, the family’s 15 year wait for answers, and the conversations surrounding the complex criminal justice issue of parole.